File a Claim

We work hard to make sure our clients are always protected from financial consequences of a loss, but accidents can unfortunately occur. In the event of a claim, our agents are ready to help assist you through the claims process.

To file a claim, contact one of our office locations Monday through Friday, from 8 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. Or, you can contact your insurance company if you either want to file the claim directly or if your claim occurs during off-hours.

Here is a listing of available claim numbers for our larger carriers:

Property & Casualty Companies


AAA of Michgan ( Kentucky Only)
Claims: 800-205-9537
Website​​​​


Erie Insurance Group
Claims: 800-367-3743
Website


Foremost Insurance Companies
Claims: 800-527-3907
Website


Motorists Insurance Group
Claims: 800-876-8766
Website


Municipal Mutal Insurance Co Of WV
Claims: 304-737-3371
Website


Panhandle Farmers Mutal Co. of WV
Claims: 888-844-2649
Website


Progressive Corporation
Claims: 800-776-4737
Website


Rockwood Casualty Insurance Group
Claims: 800-837-9062
Website


Safe Insurance Company
Claims: 800-642-3541
Website


Hartford Insurance Pool
Claims: 800-327-3636
Website


Travelers  Group
Claims: 800-252-4633
Website


West Virginia Mutual Insurance Company
Claims: 888-998-7642
Website


Westfield Group
Claims: 866-937-2663
Website

Life & Health Insurance Companies


Aetna Inc.
Claims: 800-872-3862
Website


Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield

Claims: 216-520-1300
Website


Cigna Health & Life Insurance Co.

Claims: 800-903-7711
Website


Erie Family Life Insurance Co.
Claims: 800-367-3743
Website


Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield WV

Claims: 888-644-2583
Website


Kansas City Life Insurance Company
Claims: 800-821-6164
Website


Mutual of Omaha
Claims: 800-775-1000
Website


Ohio National Life
Claims: 877-446-3010
Website


United American Insurance Co.
Website

Professional & Program Partnerships


BrickStreet Mutual Insurance Group
Claims: 866-452-7425
Website


CNA  Insurance Companies
Claims: 877-262-2727
Website


McNeil & Company
Claims: 800-822-3747
Website


Provident Life & Accident Insurance Co.
Claims: 800-447-0360
Website