Make an Online Payment

Many of our insurance carriers now accept your premium payment online. Below is a listing of the insurer links to make online payments. If your insurance company is not listed, please feel free to either mail your payment directly to the company.

Online payments or payments made via mail are not a guarantee of coverage. Please refer to your individual insurance contract regarding policy payment provisions.

Property & Casualty Companies

AAA of Michgan ( Kentucky Only)

General: 800-222-6424
Claims: 800-205-9537

Website
Claims Website
Payment Website

BrickStreet Mutual Insurance Group

General: 304-941-1000
Claims: 866-452-7425 

Website
Payment Website

CNA  Insurance Companies

General: 800-262-2000
Claims: 877-262-2727

Website
Claims Website
Payment Website


Erie Insurance Group

General: 800-458-0811
Claims: 800-367-3743

Website
Claims Website
Payment Website


Foremost Insurance Companies

General: 800-527-3905
Claims: 800-527-3907

Website
Claims Website
Payment Website

Motorists Insurance Group

General: 800-876-6642
Claims: 800-876-8766
Website
Claims Website
Payment Website

Municipal Mutual Insurance Co Of WV 

General: 304-737-3371
Claims: 304-737-3371

Website
Claims Website

Payment Website

Panhandle Farmers Mutual Co. of WV

General: 304-845-2649
Claims: 888-844-2649

Website
Claims Website
Payment Website

Progressive Corporation

General: 855-758-0945
Claims: 800-776-4737

Website
Claims Website
Payment Website

Rockwood Casualty Insurance Group

General: 814-926-4661
Claims: 800-837-9062

Website
Claims Website
Payment Website


Safe Insurance Company

General: 800-642-3541
Claims: 800-642-3541

Website
Claims Website
Payment Website

Hartford Insurance Pool

General: 800-447-7649
Claims: 800-327-3636

Website
Claims Website
Payment Website

Travelers  Group

General: 866-467-8730
Claims: 800-252-4633

Website
Claims Website
Payment Website

Westfield Group

General: 800-243-0210
Claims: 866-937-2663

Website
Claims Website
Payment Website

West Virginia Mutual Insurance Company

General: 304-343-3000
Claims: 888-998-7642

Website
Claims Website
Payment Website

Life & Health Insurance Companies


Aetna Inc.

General: 800-872-3862
Website
Claims Website
Payment Website

Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield

General: 216-520-1300
Website
Claims Website
Payment Website

Cigna Health & Life Insurance Co.

General: 800-903-7711
Claims: 800-903-7711

Website
Claims Website

Payment Website


Erie Family Life Insurance Co.
General: 800-458-0811
Claims: 800-367-3743

Website
Claims Website
Payment Website

Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield WV

General: 888-644-2583
Claims: 888-644-2583

Website
Claims Website

Payment Website

Kansas City Life Insurance Company

General: 800-821-6164
Claims: 800-821-6164

Website
Claims Website

Payment Website

Mutual of Omaha

General: 800-693-6083
Claims: 800-775-1000

Website
Claims Website
Payment Website

Ohio National Life

General: 513-794-6350
Claims: 877-446-3010

Website
Claims Website
Payment Website

 

United American Insurance Co.

General: 800-755-2137
Website
Claims Website
Payment Website

Professional & Program Partnerships

 

McNeil & Company

General: 800-822-3747
Website
Claims Website
Payment Website

Provident Life & Accident Insurance Co.

General: 800-447-0360
Claims: 800-447-0360

Website
Claims Website
Payment Website