Make a Payment Online or By Phone

Many of our insurance carriers accept premium payments online or by phone. Below is a list to make payments 24 hours a day. If your insurance company is not listed, please feel free to mail your payment directly to the company.

Online payments or payments made via mail are not a guarantee of coverage. Please refer to your individual insurance contract regarding policy payment provisions.

Property & Casualty Companies

Erie Insurance Group
General: 800-458-0811
Website
Payment Website

CNA  Insurance Companies
General: 800-262-2000
Website
Payment Website

Hartford Insurance Pool
General: 860-547-5000
Website
Payment Website


Foremost Insurance Companies
General: 800-527-3905
Website
Payment Website

Motorists Insurance Group
General: 844-362-6821
Website
Payment Website

Municipal Mutual Insurance Co Of WV 
General: 304-737-3371
Website
Payment Website

Panhandle Farmers Mutual Co. of WV
General: 304-845-2649
Website
Payment Website

Progressive Corporation
General: 855-347-3939
Website
Payment Website

Rockwood Casualty Insurance Group
General: 210-321-8400
Website
Payment Website


Safe Insurance Company
General: 304-529-2771
Website
Payment Website

Travelers  Group
General: 888-564-5043
Website
Payment Website

Westfield Group
General: 800-243-0210
Website
Payment Website

Life & Health Insurance Companies


Aetna Inc.
General: 800-872-3862
Website
Payment Website

Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield
General: 216-520-1300
Website
Payment Website

Cigna Health & Life Insurance Co.
General: 800-997-1654
Website
Payment Website


Erie Family Life Insurance Co.
General: 800-458-0811
Website
Payment Website

Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield WV
General: 800-241-5704
Website
Payment Website

Mutual of Omaha
General: 800-775-6000
Website
Payment Website

Professional & Program Partnerships

BrickStreet Mutual Insurance Group
General: 304-941-1000
Website
Payment Website

McNeil & Company
General: 800-822-3747
Website
Payment Website

Provident Life & Accident Insurance Co.
General: 412-963-1200
Website
Payment Website